GS-2 (Mains), Mains-2018 (English)

The QUAD – The Indian Perspective


What is Quadrilateral (The Quad)?

The quadrilateral is a natural expression and convergence of interests between democratic countries in the IndoPacific region and its a natural stepping stone from the very productive trilateral conversations, exercises, and cooperation between India, Japan, Australia and the US.


Formation of Quad:

> Countries that share values have an opportunity to provide alternatives to countries in the region who are seeking needed investment in their infrastructure and in their economic development.

> Chinas One Belt One Road’(OBOR) initiative which aims to create the worlds largest economic platform and, along with Xi Jinpings 20year plan to become a superpower, is worrying other global powers, resulting into formations like Quad.

> The concern is not merely about Chinas ambitious agenda but also over the absence of an alternative force to contain it. This explains the emergence of Quad’.


Strategic benefits of the QUAD:

-> Strait of Malacca is significant for trade and commerce between Indian ocean and Pacific Ocean countries. Thus, freedom of navigation is a converging interest of all Quad member.

-> Quad is expected to provide a maritime security package involve anti-piracy operations and maritime interdiction to south West Asian countries.

-> China’s expansionist policy requires a strong regional deterrent which is possible only through regional cooperation and coordination. Thus, quad is a natural choice.

-> India’s “Act east Policy” has a converging interest with the Quad, as both intended to develop rule-based regional order when comes to security or economic interests.

-> Military engagement and collaboration in humanitarian assistance/ disaster relief (HADR), joint patrols against piracy, best practices sharing, shipping and intelligence information sharing.


Economic benefits of the Quad:

1. Better market access for India in Indo-pacific region.

2. More flow of FDI to India, will increase India’s global competitiveness ranking globally.

3. Foster economic growth with better market adaptation, so more employment opportunity.

5. All these nations can help each other and other countries to move out of natural calamities.

6. Alternate funds for developing countries in Indian Ocean (IOR) region.



The Quads potential is likely to be limited by several internal differences.

>The three pillars of the IndoPacific architecture need to work in coordinationThe Quad is a crucial pillar of the peace and security architecture in the IndoPacific region, it needs to be supported by political (East Asia Summit) as well as the trade and economic pillar (APEC).
While all Quad participants are members of EAS, India is still not a member of APEC
. This lacuna needs to be remedied.

> India may need to enter into formal military arrangements and cooperation, even though this might bring with it the prospect of being dragged into a war not of its making.
As NATO has shown, sometimes a democratic military alliance is essential to maintain peace

> Washingtons indifference to the geopolitics of maritime South Asia.
It may happen that Trump
s promotion of a free and open IndoPacific regionis more focused on trade, than maritime security.

> ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) is showing a new enthusiasm for naval engagement with Beijing.
With many South
East Asian states openly acknowledging Chinas role in regional security and development, it seems unlikely a proposal aimed at the containment of Chinese naval power in Asia will find much support.


Key issues of common interest:

> Key issues of common interest in the IndoPacific regionwere discussed, with an eye on China and the aim reaching a common ground on a free and openIndoPacific.

> The boiling regional tension with China and Beijings assertiveness over the South China Sea issue, a statement from the Australian Foreign Ministry informed that freedom of navigation figured at the Quad.’

> Also, part of the discussions were proliferation threats, including North Koreas nuclear and missile issues, against which maximized pressure needs to be applied, ensuring freedom of navigation & maritime security in the IndoPacific, and countering terrorism and other issues.


Hurdles on the way:

> The main obstacle standing in the way remains the three countriesvery different ideas of how to take on China along with, to a lesser extent, the unpredictable nature of President Donald Trump.

> Though Chinas coercive behavior has forced likeminded democraciesto converge, its still an amorphous alliance with an inclusive agenda.

> The nearterm aim of the quad is not containmentof any country (though it may certainly be perceived as such in Beijing), but to ensure that the Asia Pacific and Indian Ocean regions remain free and open for multilateral trade and commerce.

> The quadis still little more than a concept. It is not a military alliance like the NATO.


Improved prospects for India:

> Facing a huge power deficit, India needs partnerships to balance China. New Delhi is rightly concerned about Beijings use of its navy to normalize Chinese dominance of the littorals, a condition that supports Beijings vision of a unipolar Asia.
Many thinks that China
s maritime strategy in the Indian Ocean involves a slow chokeof New Delhis geopolitical influence in its strategic backyard.

> India’s foreign secretary S. Jaishankar has pointed out that Indias neighbors are bound to feel more reassured of Indias (as against a rapacious Chinas) words if New Delhi has the economic, military and political backing of major powers in the region.

> The Quad has the potential to secure the region against great power conflict and provide regional connectivity and trade.


The QUAD in context of Indias Act East Policy:

> Both the Quad and Act East Policy of India serves as a counter measures to the String of Pearls theory of China.

> The Objectives of Act East Policyand Quadpolicy is on similar lines. To promote economic cooperation in Indo Pacific.

> An alliance of 4 Quad countries will mean a greater influx of trade and commerce for India which can be used to fund projects in Act Eastpolicy.

> Possibility of shifting focus from pending projects with neighbors such as MyanmarKaladan MultiModal Transport Project, IndiaMyanmarThailand highway Project.


The QUAD in context of NonAlignment Movement (NAM):

> The original conception of nonalignment was about building strong ties with all the major powers and making independent judgments about international affairs.

> The new alliances are endeavoring for peace specially in Indopacific and South Asian Region. This reminds us of ‘Peaceful Coexistence’ of Panchsheel clause.

> The alliances would preclude the aggressions like Dokhlam crisis and would be align to ‘Mutual NonAggression’. 

Being a NonAlignment Champion, India can follow a middle path with paramount importance to global peace. Its should pursue its Act East policy by engaging with ASEAN countries, RCEP members for economic goals and engaging with Quad group to increase forces connectivity and ensuring rule of lawand peace in the region without any ulterior motives.


Way ahead:

> Though a start has been made, which is important, much will depend on interoperability, cooperation and convergence.

> The art of diplomacy lies in finding the right balance. The emergence of Quadfavors India. But the emergence of China is a reality India has to deal with. Hence, India might have to build bridges with their neighbour and biggest trade partners as well.







Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s